Observer Variability: A New Approach in Evaluating Interobserver Agreement

Abstract

Existing indices of observer agreement for continuous data, such as the intraclass correlation coefficient or the concordance correlation co- efficient, measure the total observer-related variability, which includes the variabilities between and within observers. This work introduces a new in- dex that measures the interobserver variability, which is defined in terms of the distances among the ‘true values’ assigned by different observers on the same subject. The new coefficient of interobserver variability (CIV )is defined as the ratio of the interobserver and the total observer variability. We show how to estimate the CIV and how to use bootstrap and ANOVA- based methods for inference. We also develop a coefficient of excess observer variability, which compares the total observer variability to the expected to- tal observer variability when there are no differences among the observers. This coefficient is a simple function of the CIV . In addition, we show how the value of the CIV , estimated from an agreement study, can be used in the design of measurements studies. We illustrate the new concepts and methods by two examples, where (1) two radiologists used calcium scores to evaluate the severity of coronary artery arteriosclerosis, and (2) twomethods were used to measure knee joint angle.