Cooperation or competition? Proposed changes in healthcare provision in England

Abstract

The Health and Social Care Bill currently going through the UK Parliament seeks to further increase cooperation in the English National Health Service (NHS). The proposals are controversial in significant part because the benefits of competition in healthcare are uncertain. Will patients benefit from innovation and choice brought about by new providers of care or will the vulnerable be faced by geographically variable, fragmented and non-integrated services? Will there be financial savings to reinvest in patient care or will there be increased administration driven by the transaction costs of market driven care? This editorial advocates a cautious targeted approach for the implementation of competition in those areas where current NHS provision is poor rather than whole scale potentially disruptive change.