Patagial complex evolution in hummingbirds and swifts (Apodiformes): A molecular phylogenetic perspective

Abstract

Studies of the role of flight in vertebrate evolution often have focused on the propatagial muscle complex because this structure forms the wing's leading edge. However, historical narratives about the evolution of flight anatomy are compromised because traditional higher-level taxonomies typically are based in part on the propatagium itself. To avoid this circularity, I used a consensus molecular phylogeny to examine propatagial evolution in the highly aerial sister groups, hummingbirds and swifts (Apodiformes). Mapping of anatomy on molecular-based phylogeny indicates that structural variation in M. tensor propatagialis pars brevis (TPB) is congruent with the major subclades of both hummingbirds and swifts. However, the humeral tendon and broad attachment of the fleshy belly of TPB with M. extensor metacarpi radialis (EMR) most likely underwent parallel change in hummingbirds and swifts, while the distal tendon present only in hummingbirds changed from a thin sheet to a strong tendon. The combination of divergent (within hummingbirds or swifts) and parallel (between hummingbirds and swifts) evolutionary patterns implies that the taxonomic value of the propatagial complex in apodiformes depends on anatomical component and level of divergence. The congruence of anatomy with molecular phylogeny provides independent criteria for designating relatively ancestral versus derived clades of apodiformes. Based on these polarities, living hummingbirds and swifts express additional parallel trends from arboreal to more aerial foraging styles, and from depauperate to species-rich clades. Within apodiformes, the link of flight anatomy with taxonomic and ecologic diversity suggests that elaboration of locomotor modes was important for apodiform diversification, echoing a similar pattern for birds relative to their reptilian ancestors. © 2002 The Linnean Society of London.