Anticorrelation of net uptake of atmospheric CO2 by the world ocean and terrestrial biosphere in current carbon cycle models

Abstract

The rate at which atmospheric carbon dioxide (CO2) would decrease in response to a decrease in anthro- pogenic emissions or cessation (net zero emissions) is of great scientific and societal interest. Such a decrease in atmo- spheric CO2 on the centennial scale would be due essentially entirely to transfer of carbon into the world ocean (WO) and the terrestrial biosphere (TB), which are sink compartments on this timescale. The rate of decrease in excess atmospheric CO2 and the apportionment of this decrease into the two sink compartments have been examined in two prior model inter- comparison studies, subsequent either to a pulse emission of CO2 or to abrupt cessation of anthropogenic CO2 emissions. The present study examines and quantifies inter-model anti- correlation in those studies in the net rate and extent of up- take of CO2 into the two sink compartments. Specifically, in each study the time-dependent coefficients characterizing the net transfer rate into the two sink compartments (evalu- ated as the net transfer rate normalized to excess atmospheric CO2 above the pre-pulse amount for the pulse experiment or as the net transfer rate divided by excess atmospheric CO2 above the preindustrial amount for the abrupt cessation ex- periment) were found to exhibit strong anticorrelation across the participating models. That is, models for which the nor- malized rate of uptake into the WO was high exhibited low uptake rate into the TB and vice versa. This anticorrelation in net transfer rate results in anticorrelation in net uptake ex- tent into the two compartments that is substantially greater than would be expected simply from competition for excess CO2 between the two sink compartments. This anticorrela- tion, which is manifested in diminished inter-model diver- sity, can lead to artificially enhanced confidence in current understanding of the consequences of potential future reduc- tions of CO2 emissions and in the global warming potentials of non-CO2 greenhouse gases relative to that of CO2.