Combined analysis of S-alleles in European pear by pollinations and PCR-based S-genotyping; correlation between S-phenotypes and S-RNase genotypes

Abstract

Pollen-pistil incompatibility in european pear (Pyrus communis L.) compromises adequate orchard pollination and fruit set and restricts cross-fertility between cultivars suitable as parents in breeding programs. Genetic control is simple, with a single locus expressed gametophytically in pollen controlling the rejection of the pollen tube in the style. Semicompatible pollination arises when only one allele of a pollen parent matches the pistil. Semicompatible test-crosses using partially S-genotyped european pear cultivars allowed the discrimination of 14 S-alleles (S1 to S14) at the phenotypic level and the assignment of 33 cultivars to 13 incompatibility groups. Partial genomic sequences of the S-RNase gene, spanning between the C1 and C5 conserved regions, were obtained for each new S-allele identified (S 6 to S14). These sequences and those reported previously for the S1 to S5 RNases allowed a set of consensus primers amplifying all 14 S-RNase alleles to be designed. Allele-specific PCR allowed discrimination between those S-RNases giving amplification products of similar size with consensus primers. These two approaches provided a method for the molecular identification of all 14 S-alleles in european pear. With this methodology, we demonstrate that the S-RNase genotypes inferred from PCR exactly matches the S-phenotypes deduced from test-crosses. Comparison of the sequences obtained with those of S-RNases already published allowed us to relate S-alleles between studies. This will allow the prediction of cross-incompatibility among an even larger number of european pear cultivars.