Exploring Generative Reflection by Agency of Visual Practice: An Autoethnographic Study on Reflection by Noticing and Making

Abstract

This study explores generative dimensions of reflection, shifting the focus of inquiry from tracking data to generating insights by visual practice. Two authors conducted autoethnographic research through visual exercises and analyzed structural elements and outcomes of the practice. Five generative reflection stages were developed by thematic analysis of written reflection notes: 1) notice and focus, 2) translate and frame, 3) make with materials, 4) interpret, and 5) continue and connect. Themes and styles of resulting images were interpreted through compositional analysis. Based on the study findings, we discuss some types of agency found by visual practice in generating visual insights: 1) making the invisible visible, 2) de/re-constructing with visual elements, 3) filling with compositional integrity, and 4) re-styling and re-mixing. We conclude with implications of visual inquiry as a means of noticing and investigating agency in design research and creative practice for reflection.