Retraction: 'Are European birds leaving traditional wintering grounds in the Mediterranean?',[Journal of Avian Biology(2015)] by José Luis Tellería, Álvaro Ramírez and José Ignacio Aguirre

Abstract

The above article, published online on 20 January 2015 in Wiley Online Library (wileyonlinelibrary.com), has been retracted by agreement between the authors, the journal Editors in Chief, Thomas Alerstam and Jan-Åke Nilsson, the Nordic Society Oikos and John Wiley and Sons Ltd. The aim of this study was to answer the question, 'Are European birds leaving traditional wintering grounds in the Mediterranean?' Due to an analytical error the study only analysed EURING circumstance 20 ring records (see the EURING exchange code) which excludes birds hunted by shot and other ways, but not all hunted individuals. As a result, the effect of illegal hunting on ring recoveries was not controlled for in the analyses. This means that the data is affected by ring records from birds other than 'alive and probably healthy and released by ringer' (condition 8 in the EURING exchange code). The authors' intention always was to include both condition 8 and circumstance 20, but unfortunately this was not the case. When the data was reanalysed including both condition 8 and circumstance 20 recoveries, there is no longer any support for the main conclusion of the paper and the authors can only conclude that winter ring recoveries in Spain of some common passerines (robin, chiffchaff and blackcap) do not decrease. The authors apologise for this mistake and hope that the retraction will serve to prevent the spread of the unsound conclusions derived from this paper.