How do reactive aluminum and iron phases control soil organic carbon and phosphate adsorption capacity in agricultural topsoils across Japan?

Abstract

The growing number of studies suggests that the prediction of soil organic carbon (SOC) storage and persistence can be improved by accounting for variations in soil reactive metal phases. Nevertheless, the dataset on reactive metals is often limited at a national scale. In Japan, the phosphate adsorption coefficient (PAC) has been measured for agricultural soils nationwide. PAC is known to be strongly controlled by reactive metals, and hence, it can be used as a surrogate for reactive metal content. However, the relationships between SOC, reactive metals and PAC across a wide range of agricultural soils remain unclear. We thus examined these relationships using agricultural topsoils taken from 115 sites across Japan, covering two major soil great groups, Andosols and Lowland soils, as well as various land uses and soil temperature regimes (7.2–19.1°C). For the whole dataset, PAC was strongly correlated with oxalate-extractable metals (Alox + 0.5Feox: Metalox, r = 0.83) and moderately with pyrophosphate-extractable metals (Alp + 0.5Fep: Metalp, r = 0.68). These results suggest a stronger contribution of short-range-order (SRO) minerals to PAC as the former parameter reflects the content of both SRO minerals and organically complexed metals, while the latter reflects only that of organo-metal complexes. Moreover, Metalp was the best predictor of SOC contents in both Andosols (r = 0.79) and Lowland soils (r = 0.65). When only soils at near neutral soil pH range were considered, the exchangeable Ca content also co-varied with SOC in Lowland soils (n = 17). Of the two metallic elements, reactive Al phases better explained the variation of SOC and PAC in Andosols, whereas reactive Fe phases also showed similar explanatory power for PAC in Lowland soils. Our analyses also suggested that soil group (esp. erosion intensity) and land use likely impacted the SOC-Metalox relationship in Andosols, whereas environmental factors such as soil temperature and soil redox regime affected those relationships in Lowland soils. Overall, we showed that PAC is a useful surrogate for SRO minerals and organo-metal complexes and, with careful considerations of the environmental and pedogenic factors, it is potentially useful to estimate the amounts of SOC stabilized by reactive metal phases in agricultural soils across Japan.