Validity of Clinical Diagnosis in Age-associated Dementia.

Abstract

With neuropathological diagnosis as the point of reference, the validity of clinical diagnosis was studied in 50 patients who had met DSM-III-R criteria for dementia. Clinical diagnosis of ATD (dementia of Alzheimer type) was made in 14 cases, of VD (vascular dementia) in 14 cases, of others in 5 cases and of undefined in 16 cases. At necropsy, 16 cases fulfilled the histological criteria for ATD, while 15 cases were VD, 3 cases were mixed dementia and 14 cases were other CNS disorders. In 2 other cases, the neuropathological picture was considered to be nondiagnostic. The accuracy of clinical diagnosis of VD was higher than that of ATD. Clinical diagnostic sensitivity was 81.8% for ATD and 91.7% for VD; corresponding specificity was 78.3% and 86.4%. With our clinical criteria, slowly evolving VD with no clinical evidence of stroke would not be identified as VD. On the other hand, AD patients who happened to have a stroke would be diagnosed as VD. These results suggest that further investigations as to VD {its clinical course, findings of computed tomographic scan and magnetic resonance imaging) are needed for more appropriate clinical criteria. © 1993, The Japan Geriatrics Society. All rights reserved.