Objective assessment of diagnostic image quality in CT scans: what radiologists and researchers need to know

Abstract

Objectives: Quantifying diagnostic image quality (IQ) is not straightforward but essential for optimizing the balance between IQ and radiation dose, and for ensuring consistent high-quality images in CT imaging. This review provides a comprehensive overview of advanced objective reference-free IQ assessment methods for CT scans, beyond standard approaches. Methods: A literature search was performed in PubMed and Web of Science up to June 2024 to identify studies using advanced objective image quality methods on clinical CT scans. Only reference-free methods, which do not require a predefined reference image, were included. Traditional methods relying on the standard deviation of the Hounsfield units, the signal-to-noise ratio or contrast-to-noise ratio, all within a manually selected region-of-interest, were excluded. Eligible results were categorized by IQ metric (i.e., noise, contrast, spatial resolution and other) and assessment method (manual, automated, and artificial intelligence (AI)-based). Results: Thirty-five studies were included that proposed or employed reference-free IQ methods, identifying 12 noise assessment methods, 4 contrast assessment methods, 14 spatial resolution assessment methods and 7 others, based on manual, automated or AI-based approaches. Conclusion: This review emphasizes the transition from manual to fully automated approaches for IQ assessment, including the potential of AI-based methods, and it provides a reference tool for researchers and radiologists who need to make a well-considered choice in how to evaluate IQ in CT imaging. Critical relevance statement: This review examines the challenge of quantifying diagnostic CT image quality, essential for optimization studies and ensuring consistent high-quality images, by providing an overview of objective reference-free diagnostic image quality assessment methods beyond standard methods. Key Points: Quantifying diagnostic CT image quality remains a key challenge. This review summarizes objective diagnostic image quality assessment techniques beyond standard metrics. A decision tree is provided to help select optimal image quality assessment techniques.