Global validation of empirically corrected EP-Total Ozone Mapping Spectrometer (TOMS) total ozone columns using Brewer and Dobson ground-based measurements

Abstract

This article focuses on the global-scale validation of the empirically corrected Version 8 total ozone column data set acquired by the NASA Total Ozone Mapping Spectrometer (TOMS) during the period 1996-2004 when this instrument was flying aboard the Earth Probe (EP) satellite platform. This analysis is based on the use of spatially co-located, ground-based measurements from Dobson and Brewer spectrophotometers. The original EP-TOMS V8 total ozone column data set was also validated with these ground-based measurements to quantify the improvements made by the empirical correction that was necessary as a result of instrumental degradation issues occurring from the year 2000 onward that were uncorrectable by normal calibration techniques. EP-TOMS V8-corrected total ozone data present a remarkable improvement concerning the significant negative bias of around ∼3% detected in the original EP-TOMS V8 observations after the year 2000. Neither the original nor the corrected EP-TOMS satellite total ozone data sets show a significant dependence on latitude. In addition, both EP-TOMS satellite data sets overestimate the Brewer measurements for small solar zenith angles (SZA) and underestimate for large SZA, explaining a significant seasonality (∼1.5%) for cloud-free and cloudy conditions. Conversely, relative differences between EP-TOMS and Dobson present almost no dependence on SZA for cloud-free conditions and a strong dependence for cloudy conditions (from +2% for small SZA to -1% for high SZA). The dependence of the satellite ground-based relative differences on total ozone shows good agreement for column values above 250 Dobson units. Our main conclusion is that the upgrade to TOMS V8-corrected total ozone data presents a remarkable improvement. Nevertheless, despite its quality, the EP-TOMS data for the period 2000-2004 should not be used as a source for trend analysis since EP-TOMS ozone trends are empirically corrected using NOAA-16 and NOAA-17 solar backscatter ultraviolet/2 data as external references, and therefore, they are no longer considered as independent observations. Copyright 2010 by the American Geophysical Union.