Distribution of position-specific head impact severities among professional and Division I collegiate American football athletes during games

Abstract

Objective To compare the severity of head impacts between professional and Division I (D-I) collegiate football games for the purpose of improving protective equipment. Methods A total of 243 football players from the National Football League (NFL) and from D-I of the National Collegiate Athletic Association (NCAA) were equipped with instrumented mouthpieces capable of measuring six degrees-of-freedom head kinematics. Head impacts were processed using a custom algorithm and combined with game period descriptors to produce a curated dataset for analysis. Head impact severity distributions for several kinematic-based metrics were compared within position groupings between leagues. Results A total of 11 038 head impacts greater than 10 g from 1208 player-games were collected during 286 player-seasons (2019–2022). No significant differences were found between leagues in the distributions of kinematic-based metrics for all investigated position groupings (p≥0.320). The median and IQRs for peak linear acceleration for NFL and NCAA were 17.2 (9.3) g and 17.0 (8.6) g for linemen, 20.7 (13.8) g and 20.0 (13.5) g for hybrid and 21.0 (17.0) g and 20.8 (15.5) g for speed position groupings, respectively. Conclusion The absence of statistically significant differences in the distributions of head impact severity between professional and D-I collegiate football players indicates that these data can be combined for the purpose of understanding the range of loading conditions for which new protective equipment, such as position-specific helmets, should be designed. This observation underscores the potential for knowledge transfer regarding biomechanical factors affecting head loading across professional and D-I college football, highlighting crucial implications for innovation in protective equipment.