Evidence for a Temporary Positive Priming Effect in Aquatic Systems With Certain Substrates and Isotopic Discrimination of DOM Sources

Abstract

The “priming effect” (PE) is well documented in soils, but contradictory results have been reported in aquatic ecosystems. To investigate whether the presence of easily degradable labile dissolved organic matter (LDOM) changes the biodegradation rate of nonlabile DOM (NLDOM), incubations were performed with various sources of LDOM and NLDOM in microcosms amended with nutrients and a microbial inoculum. Stable carbon isotope analysis of DOM was used for the first time to estimate the PE. A significant positive PE (15%–34% of initial NLDOM) was measured, but only with mixed (glucose + amino acids) or complex (disaccharide) LDOM. Regardless of the LDOM, no PE was measured with more recalcitrant NLDOM (half-life of 128 days here), when the LDOM/NLDOM ratio was low (0.3 versus 1), and when the NLDOM and microbial inoculum were from the same water (no mixing). The presence of sediments likely enhances microbial diversity and NLDOM degradation rate, but it did not increase the PE. Microbial use of LDOM produced new microbial NLDOM that should be discriminated (here by isotopes) from initial NLDOM for accurate PE measurements. The PE was temporary and lasted about 2 weeks after one LDOM addition. In areas with frequent additions of LDOM, a long-lasting PE is expected and may significantly increase CO2 production. Exposing refractory DOM to new conditions and microbial community, such as during natural water mixing, seems to exert a strong control on its dynamics. Here, the addition of a new microbial inoculum had a stronger effect than adding LDOM or the PE.