Statistical model building and model criticism for human circadian data

Abstract

Mathematical models have played an important role in the analysis of circadian systems. The models include simulation of differential equation systems to assess the dynamic properties of a circadian system and the use of statistical models, primarily harmonic regression methods, to assess the static properties of the system. The dynamical behaviors characterized by the simulation studies are the response of the circadian pacemaker to light, its rate of decay to its limit cycle, and its response to the rest-activity cycle. The static properties are phase, amplitude, and period of the intrinsic oscillator. Formal statistical methods are not routinely employed in simulation studies, and therefore the uncertainty in inferences based on the differential equation models and their sensitivity to model specification and parameter estimation error cannot be evaluated. The harmonic regression models allow formal statistical analysis of static but not dynamical features of the circadian pacemaker. The authors present a paradigm for analyzing circadian data based on the Box iterative scheme for statistical model building. The paradigm unifies the differential equation-based simulations (direct problem) and the model fitting approach using harmonic regression techniques (inverse problem) under a single schema. The framework is illustrated with the analysis of a core-temperature data series collected under a forced desynchrony protocol. The Box iterative paradigm provides a framework for systematically constructing and analyzing models of circadian data.