Protein evolution in different cellular environments: Cytochrome b in sharks and mammals

Abstract

DNA sequences for the mitochondrial cytochrome b gene were determined for 13 species of sharks. Rates and patterns of amino acid replacement are compared for sharks and mammals. Absolute rates of cytochrome b evolution are six times slower in sharks than in mammals. Bivariate plots of the number of nonsynonymous and silent transversions are indistinguishable in the two groups, however, suggesting that the differences in amino acid replacement rates are due primarily to differences in DNA substitution rates. Patterns of amino acid replacement are also similar in the two groups. Conserved and variable regions occur in the same parts of the cytochrome b gene, and there is little evidence that the types of amino acid changes are significantly different between the groups. Similarity in the relative rates and patterns of protein change between the two groups prevails despite dramatic differences in the cellular environments of sharks and mammals. Poor penetrance of physiological differences through to rates of protein evolution provides support for the neutral theory and suggests that, for cytochrome b, patterns of evolution have been relatively constant throughout much of vertebrate history.