Supported Lipid Bilayer Platform for Characterizing the Membrane-Disruptive Behaviors of Triton X-100 and Potential Detergent Replacements

Abstract

Triton X-100 (TX-100) is a widely used detergent to prevent viral contamination of man-ufactured biologicals and biopharmaceuticals, and acts by disrupting membrane-enveloped virus particles. However, environmental concerns about ecotoxic byproducts are leading to TX-100 phase out and there is an outstanding need to identify functionally equivalent detergents that can potentially replace TX-100. To date, a few detergent candidates have been identified based on viral inactivation studies, while direct mechanistic comparison of TX-100 and potential replacements from a biophysical interaction perspective is warranted. Herein, we employed a supported lipid bilayer (SLB) platform to comparatively evaluate the membrane-disruptive properties of TX-100 and a potential replace-ment, Simulsol SL 11W (SL-11W), and identified key mechanistic differences in terms of how the two detergents interact with phospholipid membranes. Quartz crystal microbalance-dissipation (QCM-D) measurements revealed that TX-100 was more potent and induced rapid, irreversible, and complete membrane solubilization, whereas SL-11W caused more gradual, reversible membrane budding and did not induce extensive membrane solubilization. The results further demonstrated that TX-100 and SL-11W both exhibit concentration-dependent interaction behaviors and were only active at or above their respective critical micelle concentration (CMC) values. Collectively, our findings demonstrate that TX-100 and SL-11W have distinct membrane-disruptive effects in terms of potency, mechanism of action, and interaction kinetics, and the SLB platform approach can support the development of biophysical assays to efficiently test potential TX-100 replacements.