The third-order structure function in two dimensions: The Rashomon effect

Abstract

We study the third-order longitudinal structure function, S3(r), in two-dimensional turbulence. In three dimensions, there is considerable theoretical, experimental, and numerical consensus regarding the validity of Kolmogorov's arch-famous " 4/5 th law" for S3(r). By contrast, in two dimensions, two disparate cascades, changed dissipation anomalies, a large-scale drag, and other factors conspire to create several versions of the S3(r) "law." This single quantity can vary considerably when viewed from different perspectives, reminiscent of the "Rashomon effect" in anthropology. After reviewing the history and usage of S3(r) in two-dimensional turbulence, we show that S3(r) generically embodies a mixture of energy and enstrophy fluxes. Building on this result, we derive S3(r) laws for freely decaying and forced two-dimensional turbulent flows, where we also account for the effects of a large-scale drag, an inextricable feature of quasi two-dimensional turbulence in experimental and atmospheric flows. We draw attention to the caution needed in interpreting S3(r) in two-dimensional turbulence.