The Diversity of N-Glycans of Chlorella Food Supplements Challenges Current Species Classification

Abstract

N-glycans have recently emerged as highly varied elements of Chlorella strains and products. Four years and eighty samples later, the increasing N-glycan diversity calls for a re-examination in the light of concepts of species designations and product authenticity. N-glycans of commercial products were analyzed by matrix-assisted time-of-flight mass spectrometry (MALDI-TOF MS) supported by chromatography on porous graphitic carbon with mass spectrometric detection. Although 36% of 172 products were labeled C. vulgaris, only 9% presented what could be taken as a C. vulgaris type N-glycan pattern. Respectively, 5 and 20% of the products matched with C. sorokiniana strains SAG 211-8k and SAG 211-34, which, however, carry entirely different structures. Furthermore, 41% presented with one of four frequently occurring glyco-types while 26% of the samples showed unique or rare N-glycan patterns. These glycan signatures thus profoundly challenge the stated species designations. By no means do we want to question the presumed health benefits of the products or the sincerity of manufacturers. We rather aim to raise awareness of the fascinating but also concerning diversity of microalgal N-glycans and suggest it as a means for defining product identity and taxonomic classifications.