Relative effectiveness of organic and inorganic nutrient sources in improving yield, seed quality and nutrient uptake of canola

Abstract

The proper use of organic and inorganic nutrient sources is important to sustain high levels of crop production, while maintaining or enhancing soil and environmental quality. A 4-year (2009 to 2012) field experiment was established in spring 2009 on a Gray Luvisol (Typic Haplocryalf) loam soil at Star City, Saskatchewan, Canada, to de-termine the effectiveness of organic/biological (compost, wood ash [fine and granular], alfalfa pellets, distiller grain, thin stillage, glycerol, fish food additive, Penicillium bilaiae), inorganic/min-eral (granular-gypsum, rapid release elemental S [RRES], rock phosphate [granular and fine]) and chemical/synthetic (granular-ammonium nitrate, triple super phosphate and potassium sulphate) nutrient sources (amendments/chemicals) in improving seed yield, straw yield, seed quality and nutrient uptake (N, P, K and S) in seed + straw of canola. Combined application of N, P and S chemical fertilizers (NPS) produced con-siderably greater seed yield, straw yield and nu-trient uptake of canola compared to the una-mended control in all four years. In treatments receiving only organic amendments, thin stillage produced the greatest seed yield, straw yield and nutrient uptake in all years, and it was simi-lar to the NPS balanced fertilizer treatment, while fish food additive and distiller grain dry of wheat in 2009, 2011 and 2012, distiller grain dry of corn in 2009 and 2012, and compost and alfalfa pel-lets in 2011 and 2012 produced significantly greater seed yield, straw yield and nutrient up-take, when compared to the control. In treat-ments where chemical fertilizers were also ap-plied, in addition to organic amendments, ap-plication of N fertilizer increased seed yield, straw yield and nutrient uptake substantially when combined with wood ash fine in 2009, 2010, 2011 and 2012, wood ash granular in 2009, 2011 and 2012, and glycerol in 2009 and 2012 (mod-erate increase in 2012). In the chemical fertilizer treatments, there was a reduction in seed yield, straw yield and nutrient uptake of canola when only N fertilizer was applied compared to the control (significant in 2010 and 2011). Applica-tion of P along with N (NP) increased seed yield, straw yield and nutrient uptake of canola com-pared to N alone treatment, but was less than the NPS treatment in all years. Application of S along with N (NS) increased seed yield, straw yield and nutrient uptake of canola further com-pared to the NP treatment, but it was still lower than the NPS treatment in 2010 and 2011. In treatments receiving inorganic/mineral amend-ments in addition to chemical fertilizers, appli-cation of N + P fertilizers substantially increased seed yield, straw yield and nutrient uptake in treatments receiving gypsum and RRES in 2009, 2010, 2011 and 2012. This suggests the potential of gypsum and RRES in preventing S deficiency in organic crops when grown on S-deficient soils, provided other nutrients are not limiting in the soil for crop growth. Seed yield, straw yield and nutrient uptake with application of N and S fertilizers in combination with rock phosphate and/or Penicillium bilaiae were similar to N + S treatment in most cases, except in 2011 when application of finely-ground or powder rock phosphate in a combination with N + S produced significantly greater yield and nutrient uptake than N + S with granular rock phosphate. This suggests little contribution of rock phosphate Copyright © 2013 SciRes. OPEN ACCESS S. S. Malhi et al. / Agricultural Sciences 4 (2013) 1-18 2 and/or Penicillium bilaiae in improving yield and nutrient uptake of canola, and improves the per-formance of fine rock phosphate only evident in the third growing season in 2011, after three consecutive applications, but not in 2012. In conclusion, some organic amendments showed potential for improvement in organic crop pro-duction, and in some other cases highest yield and nutrient uptake were produced when or-ganic amendments were applied in combination with chemical fertilizers, or from combined ap-plication of chemical N, S and P fertilizers. The implications of these findings are that the use of some organic amendments can be feasible for improving crop yields under organic production. These findings also suggest the potential of some inorganic amendments (e.g., RRES and gypsum) in preventing S deficiency in organic crops, provided other nutrients are not limiting in the soil.