Variation in whale (Cetacea) inner ear anatomy reveals the early evolution of “specialized” high-frequency hearing sensitivity

Abstract

As fully aquatic mammals, hearing is arguably the most important sensory component of cetaceans. Increasingly, researchers have been harnessing computed tomography (CT) to investigate the details of the inner ear as they can provide clues to the hearing abilities of whales. We use microCT scans of a broad sampling of the ear bones (periotics) of primarily toothed whales (Odontoceti) to investigate the inner ear bony labyrinth shape and reconstruct hearing sensitivities among these cetaceans, including several taxa about which little is currently known. We find support for sensitivity to the lower frequency spectrum in the archaeocete Zygorhiza kochii and an early toothed mysticete cf. Aetiocetus. Oligocene odontocetes (including one from our novel dataset), stem delphinidans, and two additional species of the long-snouted eurhinodelphinids are found to have been able to hear within the narrow-band high-frequency spectrum (NBHF), which is thought to be a specialized form of hearing that evolved convergently multiple different times in extant groups to avoid predation by macroraptorial predators. Our results thus indicate that NBHF evolved as early as the Oligocene and certainly in stem delphinidans by the early Miocene, and thus may be an ancestral characteristic rather than a more recent innovation in select groups.