Bayesian stock assessment: A review and example application using the logistic model

Abstract

Bayesian statistical methods have recently been combined with conventional methods for fisheries stock assessment (e.g. catch-age analysis) to provide a conceptually elegant approach for providing fishery management advice under uncertainty. Uncertainties in the advice provided can be conveyed using posterior probability distributions (or 'posteriors') for the potential outcomes of each policy option. Posteriors can be estimated using data (e.g. catch-age data and relative abundance indices) for the fish population of interest and prior probability distributions for population model parameters (e.g. stock-recruit function parameters) based on data from similar fish populations. Despite growing interest, Bayesian methods remain accessible to relatively few. To increase the accessibility of these methods, the conceptual basis for Bayesian statistical estimation is reviewed and set in the context of fisheries stock assessment. The use of Bayesian methods is illustrated by fitting a logistic model to relative abundance indices for Namibian hake (Merlucius capensis and M. paradoxus) and presenting a decision analysis of alternative harvest policy options. Some alternative approaches are outlined for constructing prior and posterior probability distributions and some recent applications in fisheries. Some of the problems that can be encountered while implementing Bayesian methods are also discussed.