Flow-induced vibrations in closed side branch pipes and their attenuation methods

Abstract

Some problems due to flow-induced vibrations related to closed side branch pipes have been observed in thermal and nuclear power plants. Fluctuating pressure generated in the main pipes was unusually, acoustically excited in closed side branch pipes, and intense vibrations were caused at pipes and components. For example, flow-excited acoustic resonance in closed side branches of stub pipes of safety relief valves caused the failure of steam dryers in the United States Quad City Unit 2 nuclear power plant. Furthermore, there was a possibility that residual air or gas in a closed side branch pipe unexpectedly caused severe vibrations of low frequency in the feed water piping system. We have investigated the root cause and influence of air on severe vibrations. Intense fluctuating pressure was often caused by water hammer due to valve closure and it became larger in the closed side branch pipes. We showed that an additional side branch with an orifice was very effective to suppress the flow-induced acoustic resonance. Design methods of the orifice to attenuate fluctuating pressure generated by water hammer were presented considering Mach number, the pressure loss coefficient of orifice and the intensity of particle velocity. Moreover, suitability of the characteristic curve method was confirmed for evaluation of the attenuation effect of an orifice on fluctuating pressure generated by water hammer. Finally, we considered some flow-induced vibration problems related to closed side branch pipes and their attenuation methods.