99mTc-DMSA renal cortical scanning: a comparison of planar, SPECT, and SPECT/CT imaging for the detection of renal cortical scarring

Abstract

Background: The best way to assess renal cortical scarring is planar scintigraphy with 99mTc-dimercaptosuccinic acid (DMSA), while the value of single-photon emission computed tomography/computed tomography (SPECT/CT) is not well validated. The aim of the present study was to assess the value of planar, SPECT, and SPECT/CT scanning using 99mTc-DMSA in detecting renal cortical scarring. Methods: Patients with clinically suspected renal cortical scar were included in this prospective cohort. 99mTc-DMSA Planar images were obtained approximately 3–4 h after intravenous injection (IV) of 185 MBq of the tracer. SPECT/CT scans were obtained immediately after the planar ones. An expert nuclear medicine doctor who was unaware of the patient's clinical history or any previous imaging results analyzed the images. Each kidney was given a score of 0 for no obvious defects, 1 for equivocal lesions, 2 for a single defect, 3 for several defects, and 4 for non-visualized/non-functioning kidney (in CT images). The results of each method were then compared to each other. Results: One hundred eighty-six kidneys from ninety-three individuals were eligible for assessment. Planar scans detected 21 kidneys with equivocal lesions, 5 with single and 7 with multiple defects. SPECT scans detected 17 kidneys with single and 40 with multiple defects, while SPECT/CT scans revealed 5 with single and 11 with multiple defects. Only 5 of the 17 kidneys with single defects diagnosed by SPECT imaging had a scar in the SPECT/CT scans, whereas the remaining 12 had a solitary cortical cyst in the CT images. Only 11 of 40 kidneys with multiple defects on SPECT were shown to have a scar in the corresponding SPECT/CT images, whereas the rest matched to either hydro-nephrotic changes or multiple cortical cysts. Four kidneys with multiple defects on the SPECT/CT images were normal in the planar readings, were ascribed to an increase in renal background activity and a reduction in renal function. Conclusions: In cases with suspected renal cortical scar, 99mTc-DMSA SPECT/CT scanning outperformed both planar and SPECT imaging by reducing the number of false-positive SPECT readings and false-negative planar readings.