Leveraging Multi-Source Data for the Trustworthy Evaluation of the Vibrancy of Child-Friendly Cities: A Case Study of Tianjin, China

Abstract

The vitality of a city is shaped by its social structure, environmental quality, and spatial form, with child-friendliness being an essential component of urban vitality. While there are numerous qualitative studies on the relationship between child-friendliness and various indicators of urban vitality, quantitative research remains relatively scarce, leading to a lack of sufficient objective and trustworthy data to guide urban planning and the development of child-friendly cities. This paper presents an analytical framework, using Heping District in Tianjin, China, as a case study. It defines four main indicators—social vitality, environmental vitality, spatial vitality, and urban scene perception—for a trustworthy and transparent quantitative evaluation. The study integrates multi-source data, including primary education (POI) data, street view image (SVI) data, spatiotemporal big data, normalized difference vegetation index (NDVI), and large visual language models (LVLMs) for the trustworthy analysis. These data are visualized using corresponding big data and weighted analysis methods, ensuring transparent and accurate assessments of the child-friendliness of urban blocks. This research introduces an innovative and trustworthy method for evaluating the child-friendliness of urban blocks, addressing gaps in the quantitative theory of child-friendliness in urban planning. It also provides a practical and reliable tool for urban planners, offering a solid theoretical foundation to create environments that better meet the needs of children in a trustworthy manner.