Diagnosis of hepatocellular carcinoma using liquid biopsy-based biomarkers: a systematic review and network meta-analysis

Abstract

Introduction: The diagnostic performance of liquid biopsy-based biomarkers for HCC was comprehensively compared in this network meta-analysis (NMA). Methods: A thorough literature search was conducted to identify all comparative studies from January 1, 2000, to January 11, 2024. The QUADAS-2 tool was utilized to appraise the quality of studies involving diagnostic performance. R (v4.3.3) and an ANOVA model-based NMA were used to assess the diagnostic accuracy of each biomarker. Results: This study included 82 studies comprising a total of 15,024 patients.CircRNA demonstrated significantly superior performance in distinguishing HCC from healthy populations (superiority index: 3.550 (95% CI [0.143-3])) compared to other diagnostic biomarkers for HCC. “mRNA exhibited significantly superior performance in distinguishing HCC from liver disease patients (superiority index:10.621 (95% CI [7-11])) compared to other diagnostic biomarkers for HCC. Further subgroup analysis of the top-ranking liquid biopsy-based diagnostic biomarkers revealed that hsa_circ_000224 (superiority index: 3.091 (95% CI[0.143-9]) ranked remarkably higher in distinguishing HCC from both healthy populations and liver disease patients. Subgroup analysis of mRNA demonstrated that KIAA0101 mRNA (superiority index: 2.434 (95% CI [0.2-5]) ranked remarkably higher in distinguishing HCC from healthy populations and liver disease patients, respectively. Discussion: The results of this meta-analysis show that circRNA and mRNA are the first choice for HCC diagnosis. Subsequent analysis of circRNA and mRNA highlighted hsa_circ_000224, hsa_circ_0003998, KIAA0101 mRNA and GPC-3mRNA as the optimal diagnostic biomarkers for distinguishing HCC from healthy populations and liver disease patients, respectively. Well-structured prospective studies are crucial to comprehensively validate these findings. Systematic Review Registration: https://www.crd.york.ac.uk/PROSPERO/,identifier CRD42024521299.