Clinical and economic impact of a specific BCG vaccination program implemented in Prato, central Italy, involving foreign newborns on hospitalizations

Abstract

In Tuscany (Central Italy), the average annual notification rate of tuberculosis (TB) in the years 2007–2012 was 7.5–9.8 per 100,000 people, with the Local Health Unit of Prato (LHU4) showing the highest rate compared to the other regional area. Therefore, in order to reduce the burden of TB, foreign newborns in the LHU4 are being given the Bacillus Calmette-Guérin (BCG) vaccine since 2000. The aim of this study is to assess the impact of BCG vaccination in Prato, in terms of TB-related hospitalizations and costs. The regional archive containing all TB-related discharges and costs in the period 2007–2014 was consulted. Data regarding foreigners living in the LHU4 who have been vaccinated since 2000 were compared with those living in the other Tuscan LHUs and never vaccinated. These populations were then disaggregated by a threshold age of 15 y. After calculating the standardized hospitalization rates, the expected number of hospitalizations for TB among unvaccinated adults (in both populations) was found to be similar in the LHU4 and the other LHUs (165 vs. 156). However, expected number of hospitalizations among children in the other Tuscan LHUs (67) was double that of the LHU4 (34). If the same vaccine had been administrated everywhere, each year 29 hospitalizations could have been avoided and EUR 343,525 saved. Overall, BCG vaccinations cost EUR 14,879 in the LHU4, but 69 hospitalizations were avoided and EUR 107,435 saved. The introduction of the BCG immunization program in the LHU4 of Prato has led to significant reductions in the clinical and economic impact of TB.