Evolution of intra-tumoral heterogeneity across different pathological stages in papillary thyroid carcinoma

Abstract

Background: Intra-tumor heterogeneity (ITH) results from the continuous accumulation of mutations during disease progression, thus impacting patients’ clinical outcome. How the ITH evolves across papillary thyroid carcinoma (PTC) different tumor stages is lacking. Methods: We used the whole-exome sequencing data from The Cancer Genome Atlas Thyroid Cancer (TCGA-THCA) cohort to track the ITH and assessed its relationship with clinical features through different stages of the PTC progression. We further assayed the expression levels of the specific genes in papillary thyroid cancer cell lines compared to an immortalized normal thyroid epithelial cell line by qRT-PCR. Results: We revealed the timing of mutational processes and the dynamics of the temporal acquisition of somatic events during the lifetime of the PTC. ITH significantly influences the PTC patient’s survival rate and, as genetic heterogeneity increases, the prognosis gets worse in advanced tumor stages. ITH also affects the mutational architecture of each clinical stage which is subject to periodic fluctuations. Different mutational processes may cooperate to shape a stage-specific mutational spectrum during the progression from early to advanced tumor stages. Moreover, different evolutionary paths characterize PTC progression across pathological stages due to both mutations recurrently occurring in all stages in hotspot positions and distinct codon changes dominating in different stages. A different expression level of specific genes also exists in different thyroid cancer cell lines. Conclusions: Our findings suggest ITH as a potential unfavorable prognostic factor in PTC and highlight the dynamic changes in different clinical stages of PTC, providing some clues for the precision medicine and suggesting different diagnostic decisions depending on the clinical stages of patients. Finally, complete clear guidelines to define risk stratification of PTC patients are lacking; thus, this work could contribute to defining patients who need more aggressive treatments and, in turn, could reduce the social burden of this cancer.