Biased Shorts: Short Sellers' Disposition Effect and Limits to Arbitrage

Abstract

We investigate whether short sellers are subject to the disposition effect using a novel dataset that allows to identify the closing of short positions. Consistent with the disposition effect, short sellers are more likely to close a position the higher their capital gains. Furthermore, stocks with high short sale capital gains experience negative returns, suggesting that their disposition effect has an effect on stock prices. A trading strategy based on this finding achieves significant three-factor alphas. Overall, short sellers’ behavioral biases limit their ability to arbitrage away the mispricing caused by the disposition effect of other market participants.