Video-assisted thoracoscopic surgery versus open surgery for Stage I thymic epithelial tumours: A propensity score-matched study†

Abstract

OBJECTIVES: Video-assisted thoracoscopic surgery (VATS) has been increasingly used in the management of thymic epithelial tumours. However, its oncological efficacy remains to be proved. The purpose of this study is to compare the oncological outcomes following thoracoscopic versus open surgery in the case-matched groups of patients with early-stage thymic tumours from the Chinese Alliance for Research in Thymomas (ChART) retrospective database. METHODS: Between 1994 and 2012, a total of 1087 patients who underwent surgery for UICC (Union for International Cancer Control) pathological Stage I tumours from the ChART retrospective database were recruited for this study. A propensity score-matched analysis was used to compare the long-term outcomes in patients who received VATS or open surgery. RESULTS: VATS resection was performed in 271 patients (24.9%) and open surgery in 816 patients (75.1%). Before propensity score matching, the VATS group had a smaller tumour size (P = 0.002), lower grade histology (P = 0.034), lower T stage (P < 0.001) and less adjuvant therapy (P < 0.001). Propensity score matching by gender, myasthenia gravis, tumour size, histological classification, pathological T stage, extent of thymectomy, adjuvant radiotherapy and adjuvant chemotherapy identified 110 patients in each group. After matching, there was no significant difference in patient demographics, tumour characteristics or adjuvant therapy. All matched patients had R0 resection. Overall survival, disease-free survival and cumulative incidence of recurrence were only predicted by WHO histology, but not by surgical approach, in both univariable and multivariable analyses. There was no significant difference in the overall survival (85.7% vs 93.1%, P = 0.539), disease-free survival (92.5% vs 91.9%, P = 0.773), cumulative incidence of recurrence (7.1% vs 5.8%, P = 0.522) and improvement rate of myasthenia gravis (83.3% vs 88.2%, P = 0.589) between the 2 groups. CONCLUSIONS: This propensity score-matched study suggests that VATS and open surgeries are associated with similar oncological outcomes for Stage I thymic epithelial tumours. Minimally invasive surgery might be an acceptable surgical approach for early-stage thymic malignancies.