Comparing efficiencies of two selection approaches for improving Fusarium Basal Rot resistance in short-day onion after a single cycle of selection

Abstract

The development of Fusarium Basal Rot (FBR)-resistant onion cultivars through field and seedling screening approaches faces tremendous challenges due to non-uniform distribution of the disease pathogen and possible multiple mechanisms of host–plant resistance. This study compared the efficiencies of these two methods for increasing FBR resistance of short-day onion after a single selection cycle. Asymptomatic plants or bulbs of seven onion cultivars were selected using a seedling screen performed in a growth chamber or a field screening of mature bulbs. Original and selected populations were evaluated for their responses to FBR stress thereafter employing the same two methods used for screening. The field screening of mature bulbs was found unreliable in both selection and evaluation, likely due to a non-random distribution of the FBR pathogen and variable environmental factors present in the field. The seedling screening successfully increased FBR resistance in the selected cultivar populations revealed by a seedling evaluation. From the results, it is recommended to use a consistent method for both screening and evaluation to make the most selection progress.